Supreme Court Rules That Mandatory Life Without Parole For Juvenile Homocide Offenders Violates Constitution's Ban On "Cruel And Unusual Punishment"
The Supreme Court handed down its decision in Miller v. Alabama today. The majority opinion written by Justice Elena Kagan ruled that mandatory sentences of life without parole for juvenile
homicide offenders violates the Eighth Amendment.
Justice Clarence Thomas dissented:
"To reach
that result, the Court relies on two lines of precedent... Neither line
is consistent with the original understanding of the Cruel and Unusual
Punishments Clause. The Court compounds its errors
by combining these lines of precedent and extending them to reach a
result that is even less legitimate than the foundation on which it is
built... [T]he Court upsets the legislatively enacted sentencing regimes
of 29 jurisdictions without constitutional warrant... Today’s decision
invalidates a constitutionally permissible sentencing system based on
nothing more than the Court’s belief that 'its own sense of
morality...preempts that of the people and their representatives'
[Thomas dissenting in Graham v. Florida]. Because nothing in the
Constitution grants the Court the authority it exercises today, I
respectfully dissent. "
No comments:
Post a Comment